Presented to
Mrs Line Beauchamp, Minister of Sustainable Development,
Environment and Parks for Quebec
The petition, which also serves
as an information tool, remains open as long as it takes
to pass Bill 390. Your signature will be presented again
at the National Assembly at a later date.
Since the beginning of the campaign,
reusable bags have appeared all over the province and
are here to stay! Many Quebecers are now using them.
About 115 000 signatures have already
been presented by EcoContribution to the government
of Québec. To see the chronology of this campaign
from June 2005 to May 2007, click
here.
Chronology since May 2007
Since the month of May 2007, Jacques
Lalonde, founder of EcoContribution, has met three
times with a political attaché of Mrs Line
Beauchamp to present viable and efficient solutions
aiming to reduce the number of plastic bags in Quebec.
On August 10, 2007, La Presse
published a front-page article announcing that Mrs
Beauchamp was studying the possibility of a tax on
plastic shopping bags. The province of Quebec reacted
strongly to this announcement and by the end of the
day, Mrs Beauchamp promise to act on the question
before the end of the Fall session (Le
Devoir, Cyberpresse).
Myth and reality concerning
the recyclability of plastic bags
Myth - The opponents
to the reduction, the banishment or the taxation of
plastic bags purport that plastic bags represent few
problems because plastic bags are supposedly "100%
recyclable". Opponents include; the associations
of plastic producers, merchants' associations and
some major chain food stores.
Reality - Although
they are recyclable in theory, very few bags are recyclable
in reality. Often used as kitchen garbage bin liners,
the bags are soiled and no longer recyclable. Furthermore,
150,000 'clean' bags are needed to make a ton, which
is very difficult to sell because of the poor quality
of the material. EcoContribution has learned in November
2007 from a representative of Cascades Industries
that it cost $85 to prepare a ton of plastic bags,
which then sells for $10. Same problem at the City
of Sherbrooke; "Plastic a bags are a nuisance
for the recycling facilities". For the City of
Laval, the recycling of plastic bags is simply not
done, because it is too problematic and costly. For
EcoContribution, the notion de recyclability is an
illusion, misleading, because it leads people to believe
that putting all plastic bags (and other refuse) out
for garbage collection solves all environmental problems.
In fact, this only increases consumption of plastic
bags (and other goods). We must reduce at source.
Many people do this voluntarily (between 10 and 20%
of the population) by adopting reusable bags (Thank
you!) but to attain truly meaningful results, we need
to legislate and either ban or tax plastic bags.
In Québec and in
Canada
March 22, 2007- Leaf
rapids (Manitoba) was the first Canadian municipality
to ban plastic bags on its territory (CBC).
January 1, 2008- The
municipality of Huntingdon (Québec) bans plastic
bags (The
Gazette).
February 5, 2008 - The
SAQ (Quebec Liquor Board) announces that it will stop
offering plastic bags after december 31, 2008. The
SAQ estimates that since June 2005 (the same date
EcoContribution's petition went on line) the distribution
of plastic bags in its stores has gone down 15% (press
release in French).
February 11, 2008 -
The Maxi & Cie food store of the City of Sherbrooke
(Quebec) stopped giving out plastic bags to its customers
(Cyberpresse).
Other Quebec municipalities which are
thinking of passing legislation on plastic bags; Magdalen
Islands, Amqui, Sept-Îles.
Elsewhere in the world
The quantity of plastics bags used in
Ireland has been reduced by 90% after a "plastax"
was passed in 2002. One year after the tax was impose,
a survey revealed that 91% of respondents were satisfied
with the tax (Department
of the Environment, Ireland).
On October 11, 2005, France voted to
ban non biodegradable plastic bags by 2010.
On January 8, 2008, China announced that
free plastic bags will be banished as of June 1, 2008
(WikiNews).
Another tax?
One of the solutions proposed is a 20-cent
tax per bag. If we can expect the same results as
in Ireland, that would mean that the average consumption
per inhabitant would go from 500 bags per year to
50 (a 90% reduction). Therefore, the average Quebecer
would be paying $10 per year, while those people who
did use reusable bags paying much less than $10.
In fact this would be an optional
tax; the tax would not apply to those who choose to
help the environment by using reusable bags. And that
would be the purpose of the tax; to incite the population
to adopt reusable bags. And, like in Ireland, it would
work!
The environmental and financial
cost
In Quebec, close to 2 billion of these
bags are handed out to consumers each year. In Australia,
it is close to 6 billion, and in the United-States,
380 billion. Globally, the number is almost 1
trillion (1,000,000,000,000).
These plastic bags can take up to 400
years before biodegrading and represent up to 2% of
the volume of garbage in our landfills.
Those which do not go to landfill are
a source of visual pollution, are carried off by the
wind and end up floating in the ocean for years. Hundreds
of thousands of fish, turtles, birds and sea mammals
ingest them and die unnecessarily each year.
A sea
turtle suffocating
A beached
whale near death
The
contents of the whale's stomach
Please
sign the petition below.
Number of signatures
since June 24, 2005;
(of which 15,000 paper signatures)
Petition
text
Whereas non-biodegradable plastic bags represent;
a persistent and ubiquitous source
of pollution,
a danger to the environment in general
and marine animals in particular,
an unjustifiable waste of resources.
I, the undersigned, wish to ask the Minister of Sustainable
Development, Environment and Parks, and the National
Assembly of Quebec to kindly adopt an Act to reduce
the distribution of non-biodegradable plastic bags,
and that would also provide for guidelines for the
manufacturing and use of biodegradable packaging materials.
Can I do more?
Ask everyone you know to sign this
petition by visiting www.EcoContribution.com.
Click here to send an e-mail in
English or in
French. If this function is not
compatible with your e-mail software, you can
copy-and-paste the ready-made text from the
following pop-up window in English or in French into a blank e-mail. Don't forget to
add your name at the bottom of the e-mail message.
Collect signatures on paper around
you (at work, school, etc.). To download the
form, click
here.
Upon arriving at the checkout,
get the cashier's attention and say: "Hi!
I won't be needing plastic bags". Don't
wait until the goods have been bagged. Bring
your own reusable fabric or canvas bags.
Be vigilant when offered so called
biodegradable plastic bags; some are made of
starch while others of the same substance as
non biodegradable bags (polyethylene) but have
added chemicals to accelerate their brake up.
The latter are just as harmful to the environment.
On the other hand, those made of starch are
truly ecological and biodegradable. Bill 390
aims to set standards for biodegradable materials.
Until you have the chance to purchase
such reusable fabric bags or biodegradable bags
(made of starch), reuse your plastic bags several
times; always bring some with you and when you
go shopping.
Make several knots in the bags
before throwing them out. That way they are
less likely to blow in the wind and end up in
the ocean.
Avoid
paper bags. Even if they are made from recycled
material and biodegradable, they are usually
used only once before being discarded.
Also, a certain percentage of the bags are lost,
soiled, or never make it to the recycling plant.
Therefore, and despite our best intentions,
we create a need for wood pulp. Also, recycling
paper requires a lot of energy for transport,
treatment and generates some water pollution.
Q&A
Q:
What
is the difference between degradable, oxo-degradable,
biodegradable, and compostable?
A:
Please read
the standard recommended by Recyc-Québec
by clicking
here.
Q:
What
is the best solution to plastic bags?
R:
The
first tenet of recycling and recuperation
is Reduction at the source.
This means avoiding the use of a good (in
this case a new plastic bag) before it becomes
garbage. The second tenet is Reuse,
which implies using a reusable good rather
than a single use good. Therefore, it is recommended
to use reusable bags to do our shopping and
groceries and a compostable bag for kitchen
and other organic matter.